Home Environment The Economic Value of Sea Cucumbers in the Egyptian Red Sea

The Economic Value of Sea Cucumbers in the Egyptian Red Sea


Coral reefs in Egypt's Red Sea can be likened to a desert oasis: the high metabolic activity of the reef ecology system makes it a primary source of nutrients in an otherwise nutrient-poor sea. Without the reef as a source of nutrients, the entire ecosystem of the sea would collapse.

In tropical waters throughout the world, sea cucumbers are being over fished due to great demand, particularly in China, for the dried product, "beche-de-mer," believed to have aphrodisiac and curative properties. The demand is spreading, as even in Hurghada, some seafood restaurants are now offering sea cucumber as a specialty gourmet dish.


Studies on sustainable harvesting of sea cucumbers, where cucumber communities are exploited in moderation, show a very different process than that of the intensive fishing practices occurring worldwide.

Marine reserves can be likened to bank accounts: savings gain interest and so make money for the owner. So long as only the interest is spent, the capital will remain to generate more interest. However, if the capital is plundered, the interest and income will be lost. A permanent marine reserve protects the capital. As soon as it is opened to fishing, the capital is at risk. One study found that when a reef area re-opened after being closed to fishing for three and a half years, only two weeks later, intensive fishing had removed 25 percent of the stock.

As with most marine invertebrates, the main excretion products of Holothurians are ammonium and small amounts of phosphate. The concentration of phosphate and nitrates in the sediments of coral reefs is usually high compared to the logographic water surrounding most coral reefs. The recycling of these nutrients by benthos grazers is assumed to be important in maintaining the high productivity of coral reefs. It has been suggested that one of the functions of Holothurians in coral reefs is the recycling of organic matter.

 


 

From the above information, over fishing and unmanaged fishing will have an adverse affect on coral production, and the reefs will begin to deteriorate and decline over time. As this happens, the number of diving and snorkeling tourists will also decline as they head for destinations with better quality reefs. The decrease in foreign diving and snorkeling tourists will have a noticeable impact on the economy.

Two options for managing the impact of cucumber harvesting have been identified:
1. Impose a quota on sea cucumber harvesting, which is species-specific, and includes specific numbers and minimum sizes.

2- Identify large areas along the entire Egyptian Red Sea coast which are strictly "no-take" regions, and replenish the areas where sea cucumber harvesting is allowed with larvae from the no-take zones. The no-take zones will preferably be located in popular diving and snorkeling areas to help preserve the economic value of the reefs as a tourism asset.
Figure . Apparent Mutualism and Direct and Indirect Effects.

 

Read More in H2O


image009.jpg
Since 1978, by design or chance, Peter Collings has been involved in the discovery, location and identification of many wrecks in Egyptian waters,
10.jpg
The family Scorpaenidae is composed by several subfamilies which have in common a large and spiny head with a bony crest on the
ss%2001s.jpg
The wreck of the SS Thistlegorm will be inaccessible to divers for a period of one month from 15th November till 15th December 2007 whilst urgent
Banner

Coming Issue

 

Next edition in English

    next English issue will be available in March  ...

Calendar of events

October 2018 November 2018
Su Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa
1 2 3 4 5 6
7 8 9 10 11 12 13
14 15 16 17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 26 27
28 29 30 31
Post Your Event Post Your Event

More Articles

CRUISING THE RED SEA

With the Red Sea having a little too much of the good things on offer, it’s easy to retreat into clichés when writing about diving there. Aquamarine, turquoise, azure, pristine, crystal clear, ...
Read More...

The ART of Diving

This wonderful coffee-table book started out as a feature called ‘The Zen of Diving’, written by UK journalist and author Nick Hanna for a special edition of the ‘body and soul’ section of The...
Read More...

NEW EUROPEAN STANDARDS FOR DIVING

European Standards for Recreational Diving were published in early 2004 and define the state of the art for scuba diver and instructor training and the operation of dive centres and resorts. Although ...
Read More...

SAWIRIS SPEAKS

Samih Sawiris has often been described as a business visionary. He is the driving force of Orascom Touristic Projects and Development and Orascom Hotel Holdings, two of the region’s most su...
Read More...

iPOD case from Peli

So you’ve just bought your new iPOD and you want to take it everywhere with you but you are worried about it getting scratched or wet.  Well new from Peli is the i1010 case designed specifically fo...
Read More...

H2O Newsletter


Get diving news, trends, and business information delivered directly to your inbox!

Advertisement

Banner